Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

Blast from the past: Is aesthetics underrepresented in leading departments?

Back in 2014.  I think it's fair to say it's still underrepresented, just like 19th-century German philosophy and several other areas.

Blast from the past: 2011 in review

The Synthese scandal, Linda Alcoff's fake "Climate for Women" report, and more.

Blast from the past: How "professional" is the data analysis of Carolyn Dicey Jennings?

Back in 2016.

Blast from the past: Wright on McDowell...and the nature of "analytic philosophy"

Back in 2007, with discussion by readers.

Blast from the past: Best introductory books in philosophy of science and/or philosophy of particular sciences

Back in 2019, with reader suggestions.

Blast from the past: Advice on "personal statements" for PhD admissions

Back in 2007, with reader comments as well.

Blast from the past: Nietzsche and Ayn Rand: a brief comment

Originally posted in 2009, and it still gets a fair bit of traffic all these years later.

Blast from the past: "Academic freedom" for Larry Summers?

Back in 2005.  Although this incident probably helped shorten his tenure as Harvard President (there are no academic freedom rights to administrative appointments), it had no effect on his actual academic freedom, his tenured position at Harvard, and so on.

Blast from the past: Simon Critchley rides to the defense of Derrida

Back in 2007.

Blast from the past: Requiring faculty to be *on campus* five days per week

A discussion back in 2018.

Blast from the past: Philosophers, eating, ethics--a discussion of poll results

Back in 2012.

Blast from the past: Gutting on "analytic" and "Continental" philosophy

Back in 2012.

Blast from the past: "Jewish poker" philosophy

A classic from 2010.

Blast from the past: Most important/influential philosophical articles of the 20th-century

Back in 2012, with many contributions from readers.

Blast from the past: Underappreciated philosophers in the U.S. active (roughly) in the first half of the 20th-century

Back in 2012, with discussion.

Blast from the past: Philosophers behaving bizarrely in cyberspace, Dan Hicks edition

Back in 2019.  Happily, there's been no similarly disturbed repeat performance since this expose.

Blast from the past: Could Mencken write for a newspaper today?

Back in 2006.

Blast from the past: John Martin Fischer on "where the action is [was]" on Free Will and Moral Responsibility...

...back in 2006, with reader discussion.

Blast from the past: "From the bowels of cyberspace..."

Back in 2010 (before I mellowed!).

Blast from the past: Irresponsible philosophy faculty, how widespread a phenomenon?

Back in 2005, with reader discussion.  I'll open comments here in case any readers want to comment on changes in the interim.

Blast from the past: Graduate students afraid to support the open letter in defense of academic freedom

Back in early 2021.

(Addendum:  the original open letter is now available here.)

Blast from the past: Statement in defense of the academic freedom of philosophers to discuss sex and gender

Back in 2019.  Since Professor Stock was drummed out of the academy, there has been less bad behavior, although I'm sure the miscreants will rise to the occasion again should the opportunity arise.  The only hopeful news is that some of those miscreants have departed the academy altogether in the interim.

Blast from the past: megalomaniacs in M&E?

A discussion back in 2004.

Blast from the past: Fodor v. Sober on natural selection and laws

Back in 2010.  This is about as high quality as philosophy available on the Internet gets.

Blast from the past: what to look for in a book contract with an academic publisher

Back in 2018, with a discussion by readers.

Blast from the past: co-authorship in philosophy

A discussion, back in 2013.

Blast from the past: the Ward Churchill case, the First Amendment, and academic freedom

Here (2005), here (2007), and here (2009).

Blast from the past: Dora Russell, Bertrand's second wife, feminist activist and sex radical

Back in 2014.

Blast from the past: Steve Pyke's "Philosophers" on philosophy

Back in 2011.

Blast from the past: Charles Taylor wins Templeton Prize, and a discussion of who should get a "Nobel Prize in Philosophy"

Back in 2007.

Blast from the past: "How Trump Thinks"

Back in 2016.  Law professor David Noll (Rutgers) reminded me of it on Twitter, noting that it had (alas) "held up extremely well" as an analysis of the monster child.

Blast from the past: Citation networks in philosophy, 1993-2013

Back in 2013.

Blast from the past: Non-confidential tenure letters?

Back in 2013.

Blast from the past: unethical philosophers who participated in the smear campaign against Rebecca Tuvel have now issued a "white paper" on publication ethics

Back in 2019, but these miscreants are still among us, unrepentant.

Blast from the past: My most controversial statement ever, and the backlash to it

Back in 2017.

Blast from the past: What counts as "service" at your university?

A discussion back in 2010.

Blast from the past: when Errol Morris defended his views on Kripke and Kuhn

Back in 2011.

Blast from the past: best Anglophone philosophers of law since 1945...

...who were at least 60 in 2016.  One thing that is certain is that a similar poll in a generation will not be so Oxford-centric.

Blast from the past: How do you know if your paper idea is "original"?

Back in 2013, with a discussion.

Blast from past: Smear merchants at "Campus Watch" object to being correctly described

Back in 2017.

Blast from the past: Cochrane v. Krugman...or the pseudo-science of macroeconomics implodes

Back in 2009, with a discussion.

Blast from the past: "Generation Wuss"

Back in 2014.

Blast from the past: "Most influential" philosophy books in the last 20 years, based on Google Scholar

Back in 2020.  Someone was lying on Twitter about this post, which reminded me of it.

Blast from the past: Most important Anglophone philosophers since WWII up until 2000

Back in 2015, with a discussion of the results.

Blast from the past: Annals of Twitter hypocrisy: the case of "condescension from below"

Back in 2018, but not much has changed on Twitter, as we've noted before.

Blast from the past: Garrison Keillor on the Republican Party

And this was back in 2004!  It's a helluva lot worse now.

Blast from the past: Gender (or other) quotas for entering PhD classes: what do we know about their effects?

A discussion back in 2013.

Blast from the past: "The conservatives of all ages are thoroughly dishonest"

Back in 2011, but the point is timeless.

Blast from the past: recommendations of advanced introductory texts in philosophy

Back in 2015.

Blast from the past: Sean Kelly (Harvard) on the renewed interest in phenomenology

MOVING TO FRONT FROM YESTERDAY--SOME INTERESTING COMMENTS, INCLUDING FROM PROF. KELLY

Back in 2008.  How do things look today?