On what I will call the "Princeton model" the center of gravity of the department is in contemporary areas of metaphysics, epistemology, philosophy of language, mind and science, and parts of value theory, but having at least one faculty member covering the major periods of the history of Western philosophy (ancient, early modern, Kant, less often post-Kantian) is thought essential. The history of philosophy, however, is not particularly integrated with the pursuit of the contemporary "hot" topics in Anglophone "analytic" philosophy. But its serious representation is treated as important. The Princeton model is influential, and many major PhD programs follow it to varying extent: e.g., NYU, Michigan, Berkeley, UCLA, Notre Dame, North Carolina, Brown, Cornell, Wisconsin. Outside the U.S., Oxford and Toronto certainly operate this way, although both are helped by being large, so they can cover quite a lot!
On what I will call the "MIT model," the focus is almost entirely on contemporary research in analytic philosophy, with one or no lines set aside for history of philosophy: most of the history, to the extent it is taught, is taught by faculty whose primary interests are in contemporary topics. Major PhD programs largely operating on that model include Rutgers, Southern California, and the ANU.
On what I will call the "Pittsburgh model," the history of philosophy and contemporary topics are much more integrated, and it is quite common for faculty to have serious research that both includes historical figures and contemporary topics. Major programs operating on the Pittsburgh model include Harvard (not uniformly, of course), Yale, Chicago, and at least some parts of Oxford (but again, Oxford's faculty is huge). (My own preference is for the Pittsburgh Model, but it has risks, e.g., when Hegel turns out to be an inferentialist!)
I expect that the MIT Model will become more widespread, in part due to the strong placement record of MIT, Rutgers, and Southern California into other PhD-granting departments.
Recent Comments