So with 329 votes, here are the results to our latest poll. I'll note that a late surge by Economics & Philosophy and Politics, Philosophy & Economics made me wonder whether the PPE folks didn't rally their troops, but perhaps this is just indicative of the increasing popularity of PPE work. In any case, look at the vote tallies, not just the ordinal rank (e.g., #6-8 are essentially tied). (The results here, I should note, were not that different than the results of the pairwise comparison poll from last week.) You can see the 2018 poll results here.
| 1. Ethics (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices) |
| 2. Philosophy & Public Affairs loses to Ethics by 209–65 |
| 3. Journal of Political Philosophy loses to Ethics by 245–23, loses to Philosophy & Public Affairs by 220–51 |
| 4. Journal of Moral Philosophy loses to Ethics by 267–9, loses to Journal of Political Philosophy by 129–126 |
| 5. Utilitas loses to Ethics by 251–13, loses to Journal of Moral Philosophy by 135–128 |
| 6. Economics & Philosophy loses to Ethics by 227–12, loses to Utilitas by 116–111 |
| 7. Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy loses to Ethics by 249–20, loses to Economics & Philosophy by 119–118 |
| 8. Politics, Philosophy & Economics loses to Ethics by 235–12, loses to Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy by 121–120 |
| 9. Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics loses to Ethics by 245–6, loses to Politics, Philosophy & Economics by 144–79 |
| 10. Oxford Studies in Metaethics loses to Ethics by 228–7, loses to Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics by 124–81 |
| 11. Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy loses to Ethics by 225–11, loses to Oxford Studies in Metaethics by 122–80 |
| 12. The Journal of Ethics loses to Ethics by 217–6, loses to Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy by 146–46 |
| 13. Ethical Theory & Moral Practice loses to Ethics by 263–8, loses to The Journal of Ethics by 102–100 |
| 14. Social Theory & Practice loses to Ethics by 211–9, loses to Ethical Theory & Moral Practice by 114–97 |
| 15. Journal of Applied Philosophy loses to Ethics by 255–6, loses to Social Theory & Practice by 110–101 |
| 16. Social Philosophy & Policy loses to Ethics by 170–9, loses to Journal of Applied Philosophy by 89–78 |
| 17. Journal of Social Philosophy loses to Ethics by 180–6, loses to Social Philosophy & Policy by 70–66 |
| 18. Political Theory loses to Ethics by 162–8, loses to Journal of Social Philosophy by 88–57 |
| 19. Journal of Value Inquiry loses to Ethics by 208–6, loses to Political Theory by 73–68 |
| 20. European Journal of Political Theory loses to Ethics by 146–8, loses to Journal of Value Inquiry by 67–64 |
Res Publica and Public Affairs Quarterly were runners-up for the top 20. Constructive reader comments welcome. If you're going to criticize any particular journal, you'll have to do so with your full name and a valid email address (the latter will not appear).
