It turns out one of the papers recently selected by the Philosopher's Annual as one of the "ten best" of the year was, in fact, desk-rejected by one of the handful of very top journals, and then rejected, after R&R, by another top journal, before finally landing in a different top journal! So from desk rejection, to R&R rejection, to one of the "ten best" papers of the year! As the author aptly remarked: "opinions about he merits of philosophical work can vary." Indeed!
Paid Advertisements
Leiter Links
Around the Web
Leiter's Books
Categories
- "Posturing, preening wankers" (77)
- "The less they know, the less they know it" (873)
- Academic Freedom (1370)
- Advice for Academic Job Seekers (312)
- Authoritarianism and Fascism Alerts (1737)
- Blog Posts by William Edmundson (154)
- Blog Posts by Hellie or Wilson (198)
- Blog Posts by Jason Stanley (103)
- Brian Bruya (8)
- Carolyn Dicey Jennings (15)
- Carrie Jenkins (16)
- Chris Bertram (11)
- Christa Peterson (6)
- Coronavirus (444)
- Deja Vu All Over Again (Repostings of Earlier Items of Interest) (327)
- Dominic Berry (4)
- Great moments in obscure rock 'n' roll (317)
- Guest Blogger: Amy Ferrer (7)
- Guest Blogger: Barry Lam (11)
- Guest Blogger: Berit Brogaard (9)
- Guest Blogger: Christopher Pynes (40)
- Guest Blogger: Darlene Deas (17)
- Guest Blogger: Edouard Machery (5)
- Guest Blogger: Jonathan Wolff (21)
- Guest Blogger: Kieran Healy (8)
- Guest Blogger: Peter Ludlow (12)
- Guest Blogger: Richard Posner (10)
- Guest Blogger: Thomas Nadelhoffer (103)
- Hermeneutics of Suspicion (491)
- Issues in the Profession (2127)
- Jonathan Ichikawa (20)
- Joshua Stein (2)
- Justin Weinberg (25)
- Karen Kelsky ("The Professor Is In") (3)
- Kate Manne (17)
- Law School Updates (381)
- Legal Philosophy (310)
- Merciless rhetorical spankings of fanatics, villains, and ignoramuses (80)
- Navel-Gazing (376)
- Nietzsche etc. (265)
- Of Cultural Interest (4327)
- Personal Ads of the Philosophers (and other humor) (732)
- Philosophical Gourmet Report (855)
- Philosophy in the News (6384)
- Philosophy Updates (1550)
- Poems by Maurice Leiter (138)
- Reader e-mails (3)
- Restaurants (8)
- Sandra Lapointe (2)
- Sarah Braasch (5)
- Sunday Classical (formerly "Sunday Symphonies") (33)
- Texas Taliban Alerts (Intelligent Design, Religion in the Schools, etc.) (455)
- The Academy (2157)
- The New Infantilism (202)
- Twitter Red Guard (36)
- What is Philosophy? (1342)
- William Vallicella, racist right-winger (2)
- Year in Review (61)
StatCounter
Copyright Notice
- © All materials from 2003 to the present are copyrighted by Brian Leiter. All rights are reserved.
Paid Advertisements:
Advertise on LR
Recent Posts
- Vida Yao (Rice) talks about her path into philosophy and the nature of moral philosophy...
- Blast from the past: Requiring faculty to be *on campus* five days per week
- The return of Mandeville (in the Wall Street Journal, of course)
- New editor at "Locke Studies"
- Raz as a political philosopher
- Sinclair from Roehampton to Queen's U/Belfast
- Lateral moves/retirements (etc.) since the 2021 Philosophical Gourmet Report: 2023 edition
- NYU fires organic chemistry teacher for being too demanding, after student protest petition
- "Race reductionism" threatens to doom the left
- Advertising update
Recent Comments