The results of the most recent poll (with 479 votes) are below the fold. Contrary to what I had thought, however, it turns out that there are ways for sophisticated Internet users to vote multiple times in this poll, just as in the earlier pairwise poll (where it is easy to do so, but one has to vote a lot to have an impact). Despite that the results were fairly stable across both kinds of poll (a striking exception was Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society). So here is a ranking based on the average rank of each journal in both polls (avg. in parentheses), each of course subject to the limitations of on-line polling:
1. Philosophical Review (1)
2. Nous (2.5)
3. Mind (3)
4. Philosophy & Phenomenological Research (3.5)
5. Journal of Philosophy (5)
6. Australasian Journal of Philosophy (6)
7. Philosophers' Imprint (7.5)
7. Philosophical Studies (7.5)
9. Philosophical Quarterly (9)
10. Synthese (10.5)
11. Analysis (11)
12. Canadian Journal of Philosophy (12.5)
12. Ergo (12.5)
14. Erkenntnis (14.5)
15. European Journal of Philosophy (15)
16. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (16.5)
17. American Philosophical Quarterly (17)
18. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly (17.5)
19. Inquiry (18.5)
19. Journal of the American Philosophical Association (18.5)
Runners-up for the top twenty: The Monist (21.5) and Philosophical Perspectives (21.5)
Top 25 by the Condorcet method:
| 1. Philosophical Review (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices) |
| 2. Mind loses to Philosophical Review by 276–138 |
| 3. Nous loses to Philosophical Review by 300–120, loses to Mind by 230–175 |
| 4. Philosophy & Phenomenological Research loses to Philosophical Review by 327–90, loses to Nous by 271–143 |
| 5. Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 341–81, loses to Philosophy & Phenomenological Research by 233–180 |
| 6. Australasian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 355–65, loses to Journal of Philosophy by 290–128 |
| 7. Philosophers' Imprint loses to Philosophical Review by 322–82, loses to Australasian Journal of Philosophy by 214–181 |
| 8. Philosophical Studies loses to Philosophical Review by 367–42, loses to Philosophers' Imprint by 263–130 |
| 9. Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 347–44, loses to Philosophical Studies by 219–158 |
| 10. Synthese loses to Philosophical Review by 350–45, loses to Philosophical Quarterly by 209–152 |
| 11. Ergo loses to Philosophical Review by 317–63, loses to Synthese by 200–165 |
| 12. Analysis loses to Philosophical Review by 369–47, loses to Ergo by 204–178 |
| 13. Canadian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 350–37, loses to Analysis by 232–148 |
| 14. European Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 309–50, loses to Canadian Journal of Philosophy by 198–142 |
| 15. Erkenntnis loses to Philosophical Review by 337–45, loses to European Journal of Philosophy by 170–165 |
| 16. American Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 321–49, loses to Erkenntnis by 202–139 |
| 17. Inquiry loses to Philosophical Review by 307–40, loses to American Philosophical Quarterly by 166–154 |
| 18. Journal of the American Philosophical Association loses to Philosophical Review by 314–35, loses to Inquiry by 189–126 |
| 19. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 329–35, loses to Journal of the American Philosophical Association by 167–155 |
| 20. The Monist loses to Philosophical Review by 280–41, loses to Pacific Philosophical Quarterly by 171–128 |
| 21. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society loses to Philosophical Review by 330–13, loses to The Monist by 162–129 |
| 22. Philosophical Perspectives loses to Philosophical Review by 278–22, loses to Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society by 169–108 |
| 23. Thought loses to Philosophical Review by 297–16, loses to Philosophical Perspectives by 148–117 |
| 24. Analytic Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 301–32, loses to Thought by 143–139 |
| 25. Dialectica loses to Philosophical Review by 284–29, loses to Analytic Philosophy by 185–92 |
