This morning's poll got over 600 votes in only a few hours, which may mean it's a bit skewed towards those with the strongest opinions about this. But here are the results:
What is your opinion of so-called "factory farming"? | ||
Selection | Votes | |
It is a moral abomination, an animal "Holocaust" | 27% | 167 |
It is morally wrong | 54% | 332 |
It is morally neutral | 5% | 31 |
It is a morally justifiable way of providing low-cost food products to people | 13% | 82 |
It is morally commendable by bringing into existence animals who otherwise would not have existed | 1% | 5 |
617 total |
This is a quite remarkable consensus among philosophically-minded folks. I will be interested to see whether it holds for other issues. (By the way, a version of the last choice has been defended by Loren Lomasky [Virginia]. In general, it's clear that many philosophers are quite ready to dismiss the cultural and culinary traditions of hundreds of millions of people as having no moral weight. In this paper, I speculate about the likely practical limits of these moral arguments for vegetarianism.)
Recent Comments