MOVING TO FRONT FROM MAY 4--FURTHER DISCUSSION INVITED
I continue to get e-mail from readers related to this earlier thread; I think it will be more efficient to open a discussion thread here for further contributions. Do look at the earlier contributions by Debra Satz, Jose Bermudez, Matt Kotzen et al. to get an idea what is sought. I will moderate and edit for substance and discursive relevance. Thanks. (Signed comments only, valid e-mail address, which will not appear.)
ADDENDUM: Trying to moderate two threads, I've lost track about which permitted pseudonyms, which didn't. I do still require a valid e-mail address, that won't be published, and please try to keep it substantive.