We did a survey on this a couple of years ago, and I thought it might be worth trying it again, with a few new additions this time. I've left out very good journals that publish, say, only in history of philosophy, or only in value theory, limiting the survey to journals that publish in roughly a half-dozen subfields or more. We'll let this run a few days, and then see where we are. Have fun!
UPDATE: With 460 votes, and no signs on a cursory review of egregious strategic voting, here's the top 20
| 1. Philosophical Review (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices) |
| 2. Nous loses to Philosophical Review by 260–127 |
| 3. Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 262–131, loses to Nous by 202–192 |
| 4. Mind loses to Philosophical Review by 281–105, loses to Journal of Philosophy by 218–171 |
| 5. Philosophy & Phenomenological Research loses to Philosophical Review by 284–110, loses to Mind by 209–179 |
| 6. Philosophical Studies loses to Philosophical Review by 324–65, loses to Philosophy & Phenomenological Research by 297–85 |
| 7. Australasian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 331–55, loses to Philosophical Studies by 215–149 |
| 8. Analysis loses to Philosophical Review by 332–55, loses to Australasian Journal of Philosophy by 219–148 |
| 9. Philosopher's Imprint loses to Philosophical Review by 340–38, loses to Analysis by 191–175 |
| 10. Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 335–38, loses to Philosopher's Imprint by 174–166 |
| 11. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society loses to Philosophical Review by 345–25, loses to Philosophical Quarterly by 245–95 |
| 12. American Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 344–30, loses to Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society by 185–145 |
| 13. Canadian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 345–46, loses to American Philosophical Quarterly by 180–162 |
| 14. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 351–21, loses to Canadian Journal of Philosophy by 174–160 |
| 15. Synthese loses to Philosophical Review by 341–47, loses to Pacific Philosophical Quarterly by 175–170 |
| 16. Erkenntnis loses to Philosophical Review by 346–30, loses to Synthese by 194–142 |
| 17. European Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 323–49, loses to Erkenntnis by 166–154 |
| 18. Monist loses to Philosophical Review by 344–25, loses to European Journal of Philosophy by 167–158 |
| 19. Philosophical Topics loses to Philosophical Review by 333–12, loses to Monist by 174–111 |
| 20. Ratio loses to Philosophical Review by 336–33, loses to Philosophical Topics by 144–131 |
Recent Comments