So with more than 500 votes cast, the earlier poll is now closed. Here are "the top 19" journals (after which there is a drop-off in votes). Some useful information here, also some surprises.
| 1. Philosophical Review (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices) |
| 2. Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 275–125 |
| 3. Nous loses to Philosophical Review by 307–118, loses to Journal of Philosophy by 240–183 |
| 4. Mind loses to Philosophical Review by 309–108, loses to Nous by 221–192 |
| 5. Philosophy & Phenomenological Research loses to Philosophical Review by 361–80, loses to Mind by 307–132 |
| 6. Australasian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 386–65, loses to Philosophy & Phenomenological Research by 327–102 |
| 7. Philosophical Studies loses to Philosophical Review by 277–47, loses to Australasian Journal of Philosophy by 153–143 |
| 8. Analysis loses to Philosophical Review by 384–71, loses to Philosophical Studies by 259–159 |
| 9. Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 376–57, loses to Analysis by 222–179 |
| 10. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society loses to Philosophical Review by 387–44, loses to Philosophical Quarterly by 273–105 |
| 11. Philosophers' Imprint loses to Philosophical Review by 264–28, loses to Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society by 135–124 |
| 12. Philosophical Perspectives loses to Philosophical Review by 369–27, loses to Philosophers' Imprint by 167–141 |
| 13. American Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 387–42, loses to Philosophical Perspectives by 138–118 |
| 14. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly loses to Philosophical Review by 410–23, loses to American Philosophical Quarterly by 169–167 |
| 15. The Monist loses to Philosophical Review by 385–38, loses to Pacific Philosophical Quarterly by 199–102 |
| 16. Canadian Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 393–32, loses to The Monist by 161–132 |
| 17. Philosophical Topics loses to Philosophical Review by 379–12, loses to Canadian Journal of Philosophy by 197–112 |
| 18. European Journal of Philosophy loses to Philosophical Review by 265–24, loses to Philosophical Topics by 135–133 |
| 19. Ratio loses to Philosophical Review by 395–22, loses to European Journal of Philosophy by 152–134 |
Comments are open; only signed comments will be approved (an e-mail is not enough, you must sign your full name to the comment).
