Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

Blast from the past: departments ranked by citations to faculty in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Back in 2014.

The U.S. Supreme Court, abortion, and the 2022 midterm elections

The NYT coverage makes it sound like there's a real chance the Court will overrule Roe v. Wade next June, which would result in at least 20 states prohibiting abortion immediately (some will permit exceptions in cases of rape or incest, others will not even do that).  Public opinion in the benighted states of America decisively supports a right to choose abortion by a large margin--if not in all cases, then certainly in many.  A decision triggering abortion bans next June will make abortion a highly salient issue to voters in the November 2022 elections, and this issue ought to work strongly in favor of the Democrats.  Of course, all this assumes voted are counted and honored, which obviously isn't the goal in many of the 20 states that will ban abortion if the super-legislature permits them.

Strike at 58 universities in the UK...

...over pension, pay,  and working conditions.

The Rittenhouse verdict explained

A useful discussion of the case by a clinical law professor at Harvard, who explains the law very simply and clearly.  His conclusion is not that different from my far briefer one:

The quarrel, I submit, is not with the jury, or with the extrajudicial commentary that preceded the trial. The better quarrel should be with Wisconsin’s gun law. Long-standing self-defense law conspired with absurdly permissive open carry laws to create the set of conditions to make the Rittenhouse affair possible. Perhaps those of us who find the verdict troubling are better served by focusing our attention on state legislatures. I see nothing in the text of the Second Amendment or its doctrinal exegesis that compels states to permit minors to stroll about town with a rifle strapped across their shoulder. It makes no sense, and the unintended consequence of such a legal regime is a Wild Wild West mentality where citizens feel emboldened to engage in private law enforcement.

Which areas have a "Group 1" consisting of programs with a rounded mean of 5.0? (CORRECTED)

Most do not:  generally, the "Group 1" programs have a rounded mean of 4.5, meaning of course that there is some disagreement about what makes for excellence in the specialty.  But eight specialties have a "Group 1" consisting of programs (mostly only one program) with a rounded mean of 5.0, meaning specialists in those areas share more of a consensus.  Those areas and the programs with a rounded mean of 5.0 are below the fold: 

The BPhil in philosophy at Oxford

MOVING TO FRONT FROM THIS MORNING--UPDATED

This is a pretty unappealing portrait by a recent BPhil student; from his summation:

In sum, partly due to systematic funding cuts facing UK Higher Education institutions in the last few years, there are several reasons why the Oxford BPhil can be a bad choice for students (but which are not very widely known).

These not so good things are:

• -          Expensive fees
• -          Almost zero funding options
• -          Overpopulated classes
• -          Relatively little supervision
• -          Lots of deadlines and independent work
• -          Very little distinctive advantage for PhD applications

I'm opening comments for reactions or corrections to the description of the BPhil in the preceding.

UPDATE:  See the helpful response in the comments from Professor Timpson, Chair of the Philosophy Faculty Board at Oxford.

University of Rochester behaving badly!

It has suspended an English professor for reading from texts in class that included the n-word.  The Acaemic Freedom Alliance, fortunately, is on the case, and is providing legal counsel for the professor whose academic freedom rights have been violated.

Think about death, become happier

Maybe!

A brief comment on the SCOPUS database ranking of philosophers

Justin Weinberg (South Carolina) reports the results here,  noting, correctly, that the database "misses quite a bit of philosophy."   The list also misses those who are characterized as "law" or "social science," even when their work is all in philosophy.  Thus, e.g., in the "career" citations, Jeremy Waldron (NYU) would come come in just ahead of Allen Buchanan (who is 6th); Seana Shiffrin (UCLA) is just ahead of Joseph Carens (who is 154th), and I am just ahead of Michael Smith (who is 181st).    Of course, when Quine is only 177th, and Putnam 100th, there's clearly something screwy going on!

ADDENDUM:  SCOPUS's coverage of the humanities and social sciences is apparently quite poor.

PGR 2021 Preview: Biggest Moves (Up and Down) in the Overall Rankings in the UK

In the overall rankings for the UK, the programs below the fold were the biggest movers (at least 3 positions), either up or down:

2021 PGR Preview: Biggest Declines in the Overall Rankings for the U.S. Top 50

We noted the big increases (5 or more spots) in the U.S. top 50 a couple of weeks back; below the fold are the schools that dropped 5 or more spots in the 2021 PGR compared to 2017:

Scotland reports six cases of Omicron variant among people with no travel history...

...indicating "community transmission."  This fits with the speculation noted yesterday that, in fact, this variant has been circulating for awhile before South Africa and Botswana noticed it.  That would also suggest that it may not be destined to dominate Delta.  (See also Dr. Scott Gottlieb.)

UPDATE:  And here's a very optimistic take out of Australia.

ANOTHER:  This news clip of Dr. Gottlieb makes several good points, including (1) of the 61 passengers who arrived in Amsterdam from South Africa who tested positive, only about 20% had the Omicron variant (the rest were, presumably, carrying the Detla variant), suggesting that Omicron is not dominating Delta; and (2) South Africa changed its reporting protocols (on November 23) right around the time of the alleged Omicron variant spike in a way that may be quite misleading.

When "reasonable" Republicans at the NYT tell you that their party is going fascist, one should probably listen

That is certainly my takeaway from the essay by the NYT columnist David Brooks in The Atlantic.  Some excerpts, with interspersed commentary:

The first great project of the national conservatives is to man the barricades in the culture war. These people have certainly done their homework when it comes to cultural Marxism [sic]—how the left has learned to dominate culture and how the right now needs to copy their techniques. If I’d had to drink a shot every time some speaker cited Herbert Marcuse or Antonio Gramsci, I’d be dead of alcohol poisoning....

On the other hand, if he had to drink a shot for each person there who had actually read Marcuse or Gramsci, he would be a teetotaler.

The first interesting debate among the NatCons is philosophical: Should we fight to preserve the classical-liberal order or is it necessary to abandon it?

Funny, the Germans had that "philosophical debate" in the early 1930s, and it wasn't merely "philosophical."

Some of the speakers at the conference were in fact classical liberals, who believe in free speech, intellectual debate, and neutral government. Glenn Loury gave an impassioned speech against cancel culture, the illiberal left, and the hyper-racialized group consciousness that divides people into opposing racial camps. Loury asserted that as a Black man he is the proud inheritor of the great Western tradition: “Tolstoy is mine! Dickens is mine! Milton, Marx, and Einstein are mine!”....

But others argued that this sort of liberalism is a luxury we cannot afford.

I'd love to know who the "we" is that can't afford the "luxury" [sic].

The country is under assault from a Marxist oligarchy that wants to impose its own pseudo-religious doctrine. If you try to repulse that with pallid liberalism, with weak calls for free speech and tolerance, you’ll end up getting run over by those who possess fanatical zeal, economic power, and cultural might.

PGR specialties where there were not enough evaluators to rank programs based on rounded means

This year, those areas were:   American pragmatism, feminist philosophy, philosophy of art, philosophy of race, philosophy of social science.  Each had five or fewer evaluators.  (In each case, the problem was the yield on invited evaluators in terms of participants.)  Programs in these fields were broken into two groups (based on the scores submitted):  Highly Recommended, and Recommended.  So, for example, in feminist philosophy, the "highly recommended" schools for 2021 are:  Cambridge University, City University of New York Graduate Center, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, University of Chicago, and University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

More on the Omicron variant

Again from Statnews:

Levels of Covid-19 in South Africa were subdued when the variant was first detected; since that time numbers have jumped. It’s possible that means Omicron has a growth advantage over Delta, but it’s also possible that it’s riding the new surge of cases, not driving it. Some scientists hypothesized that the rise in cases has been propelled by some superspreading events, explaining why a surge was first detected primarily in Gauteng province. Now, however, cases from the variant are increasing around the country, the WHO said, but some of the increase could be tied to which infections are being sequenced....

"Forgive and forget" is not their approach when it comes to Spinoza

Professor Yitzhak Melamed, the distinguished Spinoza scholar at Johns Hopkins University, kindly gave permission to share this correspondence (click to enlarge):

UPATE:  Regarding "Epicouros," a reader points me to this.

 

Blast from the past: Most important contributors to metaethics, 1945-2000

Back in 2019, with a discussion.

Great moments in obscure rock 'n' roll: Elias Hulk, "Yesterday's Trip," 1970

Short-lived British "progressive" blues rock band of the late 1960s and early 1970s, this comes from their debut album:

 

In Memoriam: Maj. Ian Fishback (1979-2021)

Major Fishback earned a PhD in philosophy at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, and also taught philosophy at West Point.  Unlike most philosophers, however, he was actually morally courageous, exposing military abuse of prisoners in Iraq back in 2005.  His end was tragic.

(Thanks to Cheyney Ryan for the pointer.)

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 4 in Medieval Philosophy

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 4 programs in medieval philosophy (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

The Omicron variant of the coronavirus

MOVING TO FRONT FROM THIS MORNING--UPDATED

Oy veh.

UPDATE:  The W.H.O. has named the new variant Omicron, rather than Nu, as initial reports had suggested.

ANOTHER UPDATE:  From the European analogue of the CDC (my bolded emphases):

The variant is characterised by 30 changes, three small deletions and one small insertion in the spike protein, of these, 15 are in the receptor binding domain. This variant was first detected in samples collected on 11 November 2021 in Botswana and on 14 November 2021 in South Africa. As of 26 November 2021, travel-related cases have also been detected in Belgium, Hong Kong and Israel. The Omicron variant is the most divergent variant that has been detected in significant numbers during the pandemic so far, which raises concerns that it may be associated with increased transmissibility, significant reduction in vaccine effectiveness and increased risk for reinfections. As of 26 November 2021, ECDC has classified this variant as a variant of concern (VOC) due to concerns regarding immune escape and potentially increased transmissibility compared to the Delta variant.

ANOTHER (5 PM CST):   A typically informative analysis from Statnews.  Do read this.

2021 PGR Preview: Top 5 Programs in Early Modern Philosophy: 18th Century

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 5 programs in early modern  philosophy:  18th Century (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

Class, education and political divides across different countries

This is an interesting resource.

Richard Marshall interviews G.W.F. Hegel (Berlin)...

...at 3:16 AM.

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 3 Programs in Applied Ethics

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 3 programs in applied ethics (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 6 Programs in Mathematical Logic

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 6 programs in mathematical logic (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 11 in Metaethics & Moral Psychology

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 11 programs in metaethics and moral psychology (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

In Memoriam: Bernard Rollin (1943-2021)

MOVING TO FRONT FROM NOVEMBER 21--UPDATED

A longtime member of the Department of Philosophy at Colorado State University, where he was emeritus, Professor Rollin was well-known for his work on animal rights and ethics.  I will add links to memorial notices as they appear.

UPDATE:  An informative obituary here.  (Thanks to Moti Gorin for the pointer.)

New Open Access Journal: The Journal of Spinoza Studies

The Journal of Spinoza Studies (from the University of Groningen Press) will be edited by Professors Andrea Sangiacomo (University of Groningen) and Kristin Primus (UC Berkeley):

JSS is open access and authors will retain copyright under the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 License. JSS does not charge any submission fees.

JSS will publish two issues per year. The first issue, a collection of invited short essays on the future of Spinoza scholarship, will appear on Spinoza’s 390^th birthday, November 24, 2022.

JSS is now accepting submissions for the second issue and beyond. Submissions should be no longer than 10,000 words (including references and footnotes). Although all articles will appear in English, submissions may be written in Dutch, English, French, German, Hebrew, Italian, Portuguese, and Spanish. Please visit the JSS website for more information on the journal’s review process and language policy.

(Today marks the 389th anniversary of Spinzoa's birth!)

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 9 Programs in Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 9 programs in decision, rational choice, and game theory (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

"Cancelling Professor Tenure Act" in South Carolina

That's  literally the name of the legislation sponsored by 22 Republicans that would end tenure going forward, replacing it with 5-year-contracts.   (At least some lawyers explained to them that revoking tenure for existing faculty would be a breach of contract!)   It would also require all faculty (except in graduate-only departments, like law schools or medical schools) to each 2 courses each semester, which is not the norm in the natural sciences, where most faculty run labs. 

When Thatcher eliminated tenure at the universities in the UK in the late 1980, Parliament enacted a law protecting academic freedom.  Don't expect that to happen in the South Carolina case, although faculty at public universities could still assert a constitutional right to academic freedom.  The argument against eliminating tenure that seems to succeed most often with legislatures is cost and competitiveness:  tenure is important non-monetary compensation for faculty, and it will be hard to recruit them without paying them a lot more if the state schools do not offer tenure.

None of these "fictions" have anything to do with "leftism"...

...which Professor McWhorter would know if he read more Adolph Reed, but that aside, he's plainly correct and it's good to say it out loud in the NYT; an excerpt:

That selective schools regularly admit Black students with adjusted standards is undeniable. Examples include “Harvard’s race-conscious admissions program” — as U.S. Circuit Judge Sandra Lynch described it last year — and the circumstances of the well-known Gratz v. Bollinger Supreme Court decision, where this aspect of the admissions process was widely aired, as among a number of other cases over the past few decades....

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 5 Programs in 20th-Century Continental Philosophy

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 5 programs in 20th-century Continental philosophy (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 5 Programs in Philosophy of Biology

MOVING TO FRONT--ROUNDED MEAN SCORES WERE OMITTED ORIGINALLY

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 5 programs in philosophy of biology (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

Blast from the past: MIT's ups-and-downs in the Philosophical Gourmet Report

Back in 2018, but the lesson there should be borne in mind this time around too (not specifically with regard to MIT, which continued to do well, but with regard to other departments that moved up or down).

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 10 Programs in Normative Ethics

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 10 programs in normative ethics (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

The Covid wave in Europe will soon be coming to America

Dr. Eric Topol (Scripps) is worth following on Twitter for informed Covid news, and, alas, he's surely right about this too.  In Chicago, for example, daily new cases have doubled in the last two weeks (although are still well below where they were last November, a consequence of the vaccine no doubt).  This is increasingly an epidemic of the unvaccinated, of whom there are still at least one million in the city of Chicago.  UChicago requires everyone to be vaccinated, with limited exceptions for health and actual religious reasons.  In the law school, 99% of the students are vaccinated, and while there have been breakthrough cases among students this fall (classes are meeting in person, students sitting next to each other), they haven't turned into clustered outbreaks, no doubt due to the vaccine and the continued masking requirements.

 

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 4 Programs in Philosophy of Religion

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 4 programs in philosophy of religion (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

In Memoriam: Gilbert Harman (1938-2021)

MOVING TO FRONT FROM NOVEMBER 14--UPDATED

Emeritus at Princeton University, where he taught for more than a half-century until his retirement in 2017, Professor Harman made significant contributions to epistemology, philosophy of language, philosophy of mind and cognitive science, and metaethics, among other areas. He also supervised many PhD students who became well-known philosophers in their own right, including Stephen Stich, R. Jay Wallace, James Dreier, Nicholas Sturgeon, Joshua Knobe, and Richard Joyce, among others. 

I am personally grateful to him for his standard practice in his undergraduate "Systematic Ethics" class of permitting students to revise their papers after receiving comments:  a great learning experience, but a lot of work for the instructor! 

The profile of him at the time he took emeritus status is informative about his work and career.

I will add links to memorial notices as they appear.

UPDATE:  The Princeton memorial notice is here.

A comment on the Kyle Rittenhouse case in Wisconsin

As legal positivists like to say: What the law is, and what it ought to be, are two separate questions.  The law permitted Rittenhouse to interject himself into the scene of a civil disturbance, to carry a powerful rifle openly, and to defend himself against others.  The acquittal is not surprising, quite apart from the fact that the judge in the case was not very competent and a bit of a buffoon.  The problem here was not the trial, but the law:  the law should not permit civilians to own, let alone carry, military weapons, and it should impose a much higher standard for the use of deadly force for self-defense.  But this is America, and America is a very sick country alas.

Great moments in obscure rock 'n' roll: Kaledeiscope, "Banjo," 1969

We last featured this eclectic California band last year, and this is another number, an instrumental, from the same album, featuring the versatile David Lindley:

 

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 7 Programs in Philosophy of Cognitive Science

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 7 programs in philosophy of cognitive science (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 8 Programs in Metaphysics

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 8 programs in metaphysics (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

Blast from the past: On defending the powerless and vulnerable, and giving them a voice

Back in 2018.

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 14 Programs in Philosophy of Law

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 14 programs in philosophy of law (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

University of Chicago Law School will hire a Law & Philosophy Fellow for 2022-23

The ad will appear by early December (with a closing date for applications in late January).  The theme of the Law & Philosophy Workshop in 2022-23 will be "Political Realism, "covering both historical (e.g., Thucydides, Hobbes, Machiavelli) and contemporary figures and themes.   AOS:  Political philosophy, with knowledge of Workshop theme essential."  When the ad is live, I will post again about it.  Please email me with questions.

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 11 Programs in Philosophical Logic

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 11 programs in philosophical logic (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):

New Zealand's Royal Society has contempt for academic freedom and scholarly debate

This story is unbelievable--what's going on in New Zealand that would explain this craziness?

Two authors of a controversial letter on the scientific status of Māori knowledge may be expelled from a prestigious academic society, following several complaints.

News of the disciplinary process within Royal Society Te Apārangi has led some of the winners of its most significant award to threaten their own resignations over what they see as an impingement on academic freedoms.

A July letter in The Listener, signed by seven professors from the University of Auckland, raised concerns about an NCEA working group’s proposal to give mātauranga Māori (Māori knowledge) parity with other forms of Western knowledge.

The open letter said the working group's description of one potential course, as promoting “discussion and analysis of the ways in which science has been used to support the dominance of Eurocentric views (among which, its use as a rationale for colonisation of Māori and the suppression of Māori knowledge); and the notion that science is a Western European invention and itself evidence of European dominance over Māori and other indigenous peoples”, perpetuated “disturbing misunderstandings of science emerging at all levels of education and in science funding”.

“Science itself does not colonise. It has been used to aid colonisation, as have literature and art. However, science also provides immense good, as well as greatly enhanced understanding of the world.”

Unexplored questions in philosophy?

A rather eclectic group of philosophers addresses the topic.

PGR 2021 Preview: Top 6 Programs in 19th-Century Continental Philosophy

Continuing with the specialty previews, below the fold are the top 6 programs in 19th-Century Continental philosophy (with median and mode scores in parentheses after each school's name):